Quotes
Search
Essentials Popular Topics
My Favorite Forums Join Discuss to setup a list of your favorite forums.
Is an all ETF portfolio a good idea?
TopCat 04-02-2008, 11:43 AM | Post #2504447 |  8 Replies
1  

I currently have a portfolio of actively managed funds and I am considering going to an all ETF portfolio. In doing so, I am developing my own "lazy" portfolio (I posted my first attempt on the Vanguard Diehards forum as the Catnapper portfolio). After incorporating their advice and making some other tweaks, here is my second attempt.

This portfolio would be in the high six figures and, barring the unexpected, would not require principal distributions. About a third would be in non-taxable accounts.

30%     VTI     Vanguard Total Stock Market
07%     VB     Vanguard Small Cap
15%     VEU   Vanguard FTSE All-World ex-US
03%     GWX  SPDR S&P International Small Cap
05%     VNQ   Vanguard REIT Index
05%     WPS   iShares S&P World ex-US Property Index
15%     BND    Vanguard Total Bond Market
05%     IPE     SPDR Barclays Capital TIPS   
    or     WIP    SPDR DB International Government Inflation-Protected Bond
05%     BWX   SPDR Lehman Intl Treasury Bond
05%     BSV    Vanguard Short-Term Bond
05%     Cash

Is an all ETF portfolio a good idea?

Is this allocation reasonable  for long-term holding?

Would you recommend  IPE or WIP?

 Any suggestions or thoughts would be appreciated.

Related Topics
Page 1 of 1
Re: Is an all ETF portfolio a good idea?
oneslip 04-02-2008, 12:04 PM | Post #2504455
1  
As for you allocation, that is completely up to you and your time frame & risk levels. As an average investor an all ETF portfolio makes sense. Low expenses, great diversification. I have a primarily all indexed portfolio except for an actively managed micro-cap fund & individual equities. Some sectors can benefit from having active management such as small cap, internationals. I think with a long time horizon you will get respectable performance and save your self the aggravation of having to closely monitor an active fund whether the manager has changed or having a string of bad luck picking the right stocks. You'll be the last to know in these events when there are internal fund issues. Good luck!
Related Topics
Re: Is an all ETF portfolio a good idea?
dtheise1 04-05-2008, 7:26 AM | Post #2505473
0  

In my opinion VB and BSV are not really necessary.  I would add a commodity index such as RJI or DJP at 3-5%

Re: Is an all ETF portfolio a good idea?
Vixxxx 05-21-2008, 12:37 AM | Post #2520186
1  

A few suggestions,

 I'd consider replacing vb with vxf.  That'll give you mids and smalls and a lower expense ratio.  I'd also suggest replacing gwx with scz or mdd for a lower expense ratio.

As for allocation, obviously that depends on your other assets.  VNQ makes alot of sense if you rent, or don't hold a significant portion of your wealth in your home.  On the other hand, if you own a big house and a couple of vacation condos, you’re already heavily invested in real-estate, and you probably don't need more exposure to that market.

 Hope that helps

Related Topics
Re: Is an all ETF portfolio a good idea?
TomDe 05-21-2008, 9:13 AM | Post #2520261
0  

PowerShares has recently issued three new ETFs which are designed as global investments comprised of other ETFs, both equity and income. You may want to look at these as models for what you are thinking about.

 

See PCA, PAO and PTO at the PowerShares website. 

Related Topics
Re: Is an all ETF portfolio a good idea?
TopCat 05-21-2008, 11:37 AM | Post #2520311
0  

Thanks for the suggestions.

 

Re: Is an all ETF portfolio a good idea?
Vixxxx 05-22-2008, 7:58 PM | Post #2520769
0  

Take IPE over WIP.  Inflation-Protected Bonds are supposed to protect you against the threat of inflation, right?  Unless you have large assets in foreign currency, why would you need protection against foreign inflation?  Even if you did hold large amounts of foreign currency, you probably don't hold all the different currencies in the same ratio as WIP.  So why purchase insurance on something you don't own?  The other problem with WIP, and BWX for that matter, is price.  How can you justify paying out such a large expense ratio for bonds?  It throws the risk/reward ratio way out of whack IMO.  If you think you need more international exposure, you could put more in VEU.  If you think you need more bond diversification, you could add long-term bonds to compliment short-term, corporate to compliment government, or just put more in BND.

Related Topics
Re: Is an all ETF portfolio a good idea?
mstargj 05-23-2008, 8:18 PM | Post #2521130
0  
  1. Open an account at a brokerage with free trades: WellsTrade of BofA.
  2. Rebalancing: Buy when ETF is not in favor and is trading at discount to NAV. Sell when the ETF is in favor and trading at premium to NAV. Slight premium/discount always exist.
  3. Taxable account: Hold TFI/MUB for municipal bonds. And stick to broad market ETFs: VTI, VEU, VWO etc.
  4. IRA/401k: Hold dividend, small-cap and value based funds. VNQ, WPS and taxable bonds/TIPS.

In rare cases, certain mutual funds are cheaper or better than ETFs, such as VWLTX for muni bonds.

Related Topics
Post removed for violation of Terms of Use (Advertising)  
Top
Page 1 of 1
 
© Copyright 2008 Morningstar, Inc. All rights reserved. Please read our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Quotes for NASDAQ are 15 minutes delayed. All other exchanges are delayed 20 minutes.