Hi Chin,
Don't worry. If advise does not work out, I never hold the person giving it responsible. I have about 2/3 of my portfolio in efts, and use mpt. I have another third in individual stocks. I live in Boston, and am in a stock investment club. I tell everyone if their stock suggestion goes to zero, and I buy it, then I hold only myself responsible, because I use their suggestion as a guide, and then do my own analysis.
There is considerable disagreement between bogleheads, and stocks pickers about what is true. I tend to think that the mpt style of investing works better, but I would not dare mention that at my group. It would be blasphemous.
What really swayed me in that direction is I occassionally correspond with Travis Morien, who knows an enormous amount about all types of investing, and has read every book out there on stock picking, MPT, etc. He is a professional financial planner, and after all his reading, decided that the Swedroe approach was the best one.
His website is Travismorien.com.
Thanks again.
Mark