[quote user="kittydog2"]
So feel free to rate my allocation mix, which has some Josh Peter-pick income growers mixed in with some dull money spinners. I've also allocated across regions and pipeline ect. types:
1.0% APU
1.5% BPL
1.5% EDP
1.5% ETP
2.5% KMP
2.0% MMG
1.0% MMP
1.0% OKS
1.0% PAA
2.0% NS
1.0% SHL
1.0% SXL
2.0% XTEX
1.0% XTXI
=20%
[/quote]
Kitty
The bottom line is I like your approach because . . . . well, because that's what I did. I decided I liked the businesses of the pipeline MLPs and I liked their business model (no double taxation) and I liked the cash return. I wanted to be heavily invested in MLPs but I wanted to minimize company-specific risk so I purchased more than a few.
It's interesting that you titled your post 'Index Fund' because there already is an index. You can view the constituents and the history of the index at www.alerian.com. The Alerian MLP Index consists of 50 companies - not all strictly pipelines - an average holding of 2% each.
By way of comparison, you listed 13 companies (actually 14 but I'm ignoring SHL because I don't know what it is) that are in the index. Your 13 companies comprise 51.7% of the index weighting. The overall market performance of your 13 companies is probably going to wind up pretty close to the Alerian index.
I computed the weighted yield of your 13 companies - it's 6.13% on yesterday's closing prices. The yield of the Alerian index is 6.90%. The weighting of your 13 companies is a little heavier than the index toward the general partner entities with lower but growing distributions (like Magellan Holdings MGG and the Crosstex entity XTXI). I expect that your distribution growth rate will exceed that of the overall index . . . . but you're taking on a bit more risk of a distribution cut because of the nature of the compensation deals between the limited partner entity and the general partner.
I found it interesting that you allocated twice the amount to the Magellan GP, MGG, than you did the Magellan limited partner entity MMP but only half as much to the Crosstex GP, XTXI, as you did the Crosstex limited partner entity XTEX. Were you swayed by Josh's personal holdings?
As for me, I hold 19 entities for about 32% of my total - an average holding of 1.68%, not that much different than what you're thinking. My current yield on the 19 is 6.62% vs. the 6.90% index yield and the recent growth of distributions has been just a tad over 7%. My 19 make up 63.4% of the Alerian index so my market performance is about the same. (The index is down 1.50% YTD and my 19 are down 0.64%.)
My largest three holdings are Magellan MMP and MGG at 6.5%, Kinder Morgan KMP and KMR at 5.2% and Oneok OKS at 2.6%.
The largest three components of the Alerian index are Kinder Morgan KMP and KMR at 16.0%, Enterprise EPD at 10.6% and Plains All American PAA at 5.7%.
I also looked at the ratio of current price to Morningstar fair value for your 13 companies. If you bought them all today in equal proportions you'd be buying at 84.7% of fair value. According to Morningstar, the best values today are NuStar NS, Energy Transfer ETP, Plains All American PAA and Crosstex XTEX.
I've just assumed that you're contemplating this commitment in a taxable situation. I estimate that, if you were to commit $100,000 to these 13 companies that you will receive distributions over the next 12 months of $6,130 and that you will owe about $153 federal tax on that distribution. (OK, I can't be that precise but you know what I'm saying . . . . )
Regards.
Cliff