ETF for High-Quality U.S. Blue Chips??
MAXMAX 
02-12-2008, 10:32 PM | Post #2487180 |  8 Replies
Re the equity portion of Jeremy Grantham's porfolio, he says, "My favorite bet on Jan. 1 and today, for that matter, is going long very-high-quality U.S. blue chips with 50% of my dough, and long emerging markets for 50%, and shorting the Russell 2000 for 100%, or a complete hedge....We always defined high-quality companies as those with high and stable returns and low debt. Recently, we had to override, and exclude several banks from that list. Whether you like it or not, you have got to treat banks separately."
...So your suggestions for an ETF that fits the criteria  will be appreciated . Am considering OEF and DIA, but right now I have a hard time sorting out how the many other specialized  large-cap ETFs slice the category.
...Many thanks for your input.
8 Replies
Re: ETF for High-Quality U.S. Blue Chips??
02-13-2008, 1:51 AM | Post #2487199
Hide

The best vehicle I can think of is an open-end fund, called Dreyfus Appreciation (DGAGX). It's overweight in consumer goods and energy companies... so stocks like P&G, Pepsi, Walgreens, Exxon, etc.

I suspect Grantham wouldn't be too happy about some of the financial stocks in DIA, but many of the 30 stocks fit his description.

Regards,

Duane

Re: ETF for High-Quality U.S. Blue Chips??
02-13-2008, 8:02 PM | Post #2487495
Hide

Check out Vanguard MGK and others (larg caps), as well as Wisdom Tree ETFs. 

 mP

 

Thanks Duane...
02-14-2008, 12:05 AM | Post #2487556
Hide

I once owned DGAGX, Bought it many years ago (15?) for an IRA after reading a Barron's interview with Fayez Sarofim, who has managed the fund since 1984. Though it only holds 60 stocks (turnover is virtually nil), it very closely tracks the S&P every year. As I wasn't seeking an S&P or Total Market index for that part of my portfolio, I decided to sell DGAGX. I don't remember now what I replaced it with. 

..Good point about the financials in DIA..

Thanks mP...
02-14-2008, 12:08 AM | Post #2487557
Hide
I'll do that. Read something somewhere in M* about MGK....The Wisdom Tree group has an interesting pedigree and concept, but I haven't yet looked closely at their funds.
Re: Thanks mP...
02-16-2008, 10:38 AM | Post #2488309
Hide
I would think that an ETF that follows those mega cap companies would do. Russell Top 50 (XLG) comes to mind. Erwin
Re: ETF for High-Quality U.S. Blue Chips??
03-26-2008, 9:45 PM | Post #2502083
Hide

If your a value investor look at MGV the value counterpoint to MGK from Vanguard.

There are some banks, but the banks in its portfolio seem in good postion to whether the storm. 

About half the stocks are wide moat stocks selling at about a 20% discount according to Morningstar.

helmut 

 

 

Re: ETF for High-Quality U.S. Blue Chips??
03-27-2008, 3:53 PM | Post #2502388
Hide

Hi,

An ETF you might want to consider is XLP (Consumer Staples Select Sector SPDR). 

The biggest holding is P&G, which another poster suggested.  Other holdings include Coke, Pepsi, Costco, CVS, and a couple tobacco stocks.  Also, Bud and Coors.

I like this ETF because it has relatively low volatility, has zero exposure to sub-prime, pays a dividend, and you can take comfort when you see your products actually being purchased in line at Wal-Mart (one of the top ten holdings, by the way).

But I don't own it at the moment.

I'd look for a price below $27, if you can get it (has the market truly turned a corner?).  Last year I bought it at $27.20, so I feel comfortable recommending it below $27.  That, btw, is the type of specific advice I'd like to get from others on these boards.  Always do your own due diligence, of course, but I believe XLP's a winner as a short-term play or longer term.

Another possibility, although it's not an ETF, is Jensen (JENSX).  This is the first fund that comes to mind when someone mentions quality U.S. companies, because they have a strict discipline in terms of what they buy.  Stryker, the joint replacement firm, is currently the largest holding, I believe.  I owned this fund as well, but sold it back in November.  

William 

Re: ETF for High-Quality U.S. Blue Chips??
03-28-2008, 9:58 AM | Post #2502584
Hide
There is an elements ETF that is based on Morningstars "wide moat" stocks. It has done well YTD and may be an interesting choice. The ticker is WMW