Welcome! Please Log In
Go
Essentials Popular Topics
My Favorite Forums Join Discuss to setup a list of your favorite forums.
Storytime for Al, et al
hurleyhuckster 05-03-2008, 9:19 PM | Post #2514402 |  21 Replies
0  

Hi Al and others,

I know your busy and probably dont have much time to read through all my ramblings so I will TRY to be brief.

Besides, I need to slow down, I see my moniker on like the last four posts, and dont want to pollute the forum :o)

Here are some of your quotes from the other post.

"I can honestly tell you that most folks do not zero in on costs."

"Nobody discussed the cost. Neither sister, one here and one outside Philly, asked about the cost of what was happening. Now I did not bring it up as I was dealing with trust document and the ins and outs. Never has either sister ever to my knowledge asked about cost."

"It would not occur to me that there is a free lunch somewhere. I suspect most folks figure someone is paid somehow."

I just wanted to share some thoughts and my experience with you and others.  I posted a similiar version of my story a while ago on this forum, I believe.

I think once a relationship and trust is established then it may not be so important to zero in the costs of every little thing. However, I think at the onset, that it is important for the client to understand HOW it is you are compensated. I am sure this is not a problem for you, like you said they have to figure your paid somehow.  The problem is, they should not have to "figure somehow".  It should be clear.

Many moons ago I took a financial planning course offered through an extension of the local community college. The guy who taught the coarse was a financial planner and a great teacher and really nice guy. The course was worth every penny and then some as it changed the course of my life. At the end of the course he offered all participants a "FREE" consultation at this office. Pretty smart tactic to steer us newbies to his office. Naturally, we took him up on it. Went back for a second follow up visit. Rolled over 401k, Started Roth, Purchased Term Life Insurance. Now ofcourse, I expected to pay for these services. The guy was great, I did not expect this for free. I was more than willing to pay. So I waited and waited to receive the bill, because I always pay my debts promptly. I waited and waited. No bill. He never offered explanation at initial visit of how he would be paid and I never asked. I should of asked, yes. The "idea" that the initial consulation was free led me to believe that I would be paying for his time on an hourly basis or something like that, but never asked, he never offered.

I still feel today that this guy for the most part did right by me. Out of the products he sold, he did right by me. He did not push whole life on me, he sold me suitable share classes, like I said the guy was great!

It just did not click with me, perhaps I was naive. I still could not beleive he did not send a bill, how does this guy make any money? The practice of AF not showing the load on statements (that has changed now) and using MOP instead of NAV worked and the cost eluded me.

I came across the term no-load funds a few times and became curious what it meant. Researched on web, I discovered how this guy was paid. Ofcourse he deserved it, but I felt "hoodwinked", "tricked" since he did not tell me this. Yes, I did not ask, my mistake. I would of had no problem with this, I did expect to pay him for his services.  I checked my AF statements, I could not figure it out.  Back then I dont remember the footnotes they use now.  I discovered how to read the statement with the MOP.  I felt taken like they were trying to fool me.  It was not the amount of money, it was the way they acquired it, through what I percieved at the time, as deception.

It was this web search that started my journey of discovery and to becoming an informed investor. If he had disclosed how he was paid, I would not of ran for the door, I expected to pay. I might of never done that search, I might of never stopped investing in AF funds.  It was the bitter feeling that made me keep searching for more information, the continous search then uncovered understanding for his way of being compensated and the bitterness faded (he is a nice guy), then the search continued uncovering a joy, a yearning, a true love I have of this topic of investing.  The search continues to this very day, years later.

I realize that your not this guy and my story probably does not apply to you and your relationships. I also understand you were talking about the actual costs of things and not necessarily HOW you were paid, as your customers may already understand this. I just thought you might appreciate the fact that if he had disclosed up front I might still be investing with him today. He is still the advisor on record, enjoying the trail fee, on my small pile of existing AF money.  However, as I ramp up my savings/investments to unprecedented levels, he is not participating in that joy!

Thats my story, and I'm stickin' to it.  Hope you enjoyed it.

The very best to you, Al.

Brian

Related Topics
Page 2 of 2 | < Previous 1 2
Re: WELL THEN
Gregory 05-05-2008, 12:41 PM | Post #2514877
0  
df21084:
Gregory:

Al, when I engage my lawyer to write my will or my revoc. trust, it's a one-time fee, not ongoing.  By your analogy, the lawyer would be extracting a commission/fee for each year the will or trust is in effect!

Greg

 

Unless you update your will.

 

And then it's another ONE-TIME fee.  Again, the lawyer does not extract never-ending fees for the entire lifetime of the will or trust, correct?

Greg

 

Related Topics
Re: Brian - DIY portfolio
leedwards 05-07-2008, 2:19 PM | Post #2515550
0  

Hi Brian,

Do you mind sharing the funds you own after you started investing on your own?

Thanks.

Lee

Related Topics
Re: Brian - DIY portfolio
hurleyhuckster 05-07-2008, 11:55 PM | Post #2515672
0  

Lee,

I will try to get back to you tommorrow.

Brian

Back at ya Lee!
hurleyhuckster 05-10-2008, 3:47 PM | Post #2516542
0  

Hi Lee,

Thank you for your inquiry.  Sorry for the delay, I had to mull this over for a while and no one has ever asked me this before. 

Unfortunately, I am going to have to decline your request.

It serves neither you or I any useful purpose really. I don’t want to influence you and I am not seeking specific advice. I am the only one who understands all the details about my personal situation, risk tolerance etc…and I am not comfortable disclosing that information.

I don’t think anyone should follow someone elses portfolio, especially, on these boards. Its just too hard to really understand the whole enchilada about someone here or to even know if people are for real.  I can just imagine how many people reading these boards jump into an investment because someone else likes it or they just mentioned that they own it.  The problem with that is we just dont really know much about these people and why they may be investing in what they do.  This is why I dont act on specific investment advice here and dont offer it.  I am not saying you would act on anything I say, and perhaps your just curious.

What works for me could be dangerous to someone else. Besides, I don’t want to be made fun of or ridiculed either :o)

Besides, trust me, there are much more experienced investors here that may be more than happy to share this information with you, I am still just a newbie at all of this.

Taylor on this forum instilled almost like an engram on my brain the idea of "knowing what you own and why you own it".  Look at your existing portfolio, at each holding and go through this excercise.  It may be tough, and you may not complete it to 100% satisfaction, but it will be a great learning process, one you can improve on as you learn.  I know it can seem silly sometimes everyone making a big deal about this and goals and such.  I mean we do this to make money right?  I struggled with this concept for a while and still do at times.  I think it is easier to quantify this stuff when your getting older and have a nice pile of loot.  For us young po' folk, we just want the best returns we can get for the possibility of retiring rather than working to death right?  It helps to marry a fine woman with a great career, like I did :o) 

Anyway I am starting to ramble and have to pick up my daughter from play practice.  Hope I have been somewhat helpful.

I would be more than happy to partake in any discussions and offer what I can, if you have any ideas or questions.

I hope you undertand.

Good Luck and See ya around.

Related Topics
No problems, Brian.
leedwards 05-12-2008, 2:51 PM | Post #2517136
0  

I respect your opinion. As you stated, I was only curious on what you own since you decided to go solo, I wasn't going to offer any advise (wish I could), or make any comments, hey, it's your life, right?

With that said, how about instead of listing the individual funds, can you tell us about the fund company you have decided to invest with, hope that is not too personal for you.

Regards,

Lee 

 

Related Topics
Re: No problems, Brian.
hurleyhuckster 05-12-2008, 9:26 PM | Post #2517247
0  

Lee, 

I like Vanguard for there lowest costs and index funds.  I like T.Rowe Price for there low initial minimums, large array of active funds, albeit not the lowest costs.  I also like Dodge & Cox for there conservative, stodgy, longterm focus, long history, discipline, and not trying to be in the "spotlight".

There all no-load and below average cost.

I still love AF too, I just wont currently invest due to the load.  If I only had $1M.............

Just my ideas.

The very best,

Brian

Related Topics
Top
Page 2 of 2 | < Previous 1 2
 
© Copyright 2008 Morningstar, Inc. All rights reserved. Please read our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Quotes for NASDAQ are 15 minutes delayed. All other exchanges are delayed 20 minutes.