Quotes
Search
Essentials Popular Topics
My Favorite Forums Join Discuss to setup a list of your favorite forums.
AMECX vs. CAIBX vs. combo of the two
KCallie 04-16-2008, 10:42 AM | Post #2508838 |  20 Replies
3  

I am deciding whether to place $25k that is coming due from a CD soon in either AMECX, CAIBX or a combo of the two.  I currently have $25k in each of AMECX and CAIBX.

The shares would be held in my IRA.  I am in retirement currently (68) and will use the dividends as income and reinvest any capital gains distributions.  I am in fairly good health (expect to live to 80 but probably won't make it to 90). 

If I invested the entire $25k in AMECX at current price (17.96) that would give me 1392 shares.  Their last dividend was 19.5c per share for a dividend of $271.  If I invested the entire $25k in CAIBX at current price (58.1) that would give me 430 shares.  Their last dividend was 52c per share for a dividend of $224.

I have other investments in American Funds and will pay a 1.5% load if I invest in these funds.  I am not concerned about the load so much as current and future income stream and long term capital preservation in light of inflation.

I would like to hear other's thoughts on these two funds compared to each other given that I already have $25k in each fund.  I have other investments but don't want to get into those right now because I have made the decision to go with either all $25k in one of the funds or a combo of the two.  Thanks for any input!

Related Topics
Page 2 of 2 | < Previous 1 2
Re: AMECX vs. CAIBX vs. combo of the two
RettW 04-20-2008, 11:26 AM | Post #2509972
0  
 Shouldn't you include the 5.75% front end load you lost for every investment in AMECX and CAIBX ?
Related Topics
Re: AMECX vs. CAIBX vs. combo of the two
Biggix 04-20-2008, 7:41 PM | Post #2510071
0  

Hi,

This would not be the case as evidenced by the information provided at the start of this thread.

Wayne.

Re: AMECX vs. CAIBX vs. combo of the two
Biggix 04-20-2008, 7:42 PM | Post #2510072
0  

EL Toro II,

Thanks,

Wayne.

Re: AMECX vs. CAIBX vs. combo of the two
KCallie 04-20-2008, 8:21 PM | Post #2510079
0  
RettW:
 Shouldn't you include the 5.75% front end load you lost for every investment in AMECX and CAIBX ?
I pay 1.5% load because of my other investments, but regardless, my question was about the merits of AMECX vs. CAIBX and since the load is the same for both, I don't see how it impacts my decision.
Related Topics
Re: AMECX vs. CAIBX vs. combo of the two
KCallie 04-20-2008, 8:30 PM | Post #2510081
0  
El Toro II:

You need to be especially careful when you use most of the internet comparative multi-year graphing tools as most ONLY reflect NAV and do NOT include distributions from dividends & capital gains as Wayne mentioned, which therefore gives a false presentation of reality! However, I think Fidelity has a tool which does. Try typing in "fund compare" into the search box on Fidelity's website and follow the "fund compare" link, enter the funds to be compared & click "compare" and then "chart view" and see if you get a more realistic historic presentation of the funds you're interesting in!

Best wishes for Safe & Prosperous times!
 

Thanks for the tip!

Related Topics
Top
Page 2 of 2 | < Previous 1 2
 
© Copyright 2008 Morningstar, Inc. All rights reserved. Please read our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Quotes for NASDAQ are 15 minutes delayed. All other exchanges are delayed 20 minutes.